To our children it’s already history, but to us it seems like “only yesterday.” Too soon, really, to come to an informed conclusion about what it all meant and whether the response was justified or not. Or even whether it “changed America forever,” as every commentator claimed at the time. But it happened, we know who to blame, and we remember what we felt. How do we communicate it to the kids? (Scroll to the end for some suggestions for adults!)
14 Cows for America, by Carmen Agra Deedy, illustrated by Thomas Gonzales. Peachtree, 2009, 32 pages.
Wilson Kimeli Kaiyomah is returning to his home village in Kenya as this story opens. He is a Maasai, and though he’s been studying medicine in New York City, his heart still beats to the rhythm of his cattle-herding people. “A child asks if he has brought any stories. He nods. He has brought with him one story. It has burned a hole in his heart.” Kimeli was in New York the day the planes hit, and now, three seasons later, his people are hearing about it for the first time. The event is old, their shock and sorrow are brand-new. Kemeli has returned in order to offer a blessing to America, something he learned from the elders in his village: “To heal a sorrowing heart, give something that is dear to your own.” He has saved enough money to buy a cow—the most valuable possession in that culture—and now he wants to purchase it for America. What happens next should bring a lump to any reader’s throat, helped along by the stunning illustrations. By no means is it a complete comment on 9/11, and it isn’t meant to be taken that way. So how to take it? Some readers may over-sentimentalize it, and others may reject it as sentimentalism, but let’s walk between those opposites:
Because there is no nation so powerful it cannot be wounded,/Nor a people so small they cannot offer mighty comfort.
The story begins way back in 1931, while the Empire state building was going up and jazz clubs were in full swing, and the John J. Harvey fireboat was launched into New York harbor to begin many years of service. In 1995 the boat was retired and headed for the scrapheap when a band of enthusiasts bought her and fixed her up to run again—even though they never expected she would fight fires. “But then on September 11, 2001, something so huge and horrible happened that the whole world shook.” The Harvey crew of amateurs quickly assembled and reported for duty, thinking they could ferry people from lower Manhattan. But the water pipes under the Trade Center were broken, making fire trucks useless. So the Harvey joined the two remaining fire boats to pump water out of the harbor. After four days, the fire was under control. “Finally, it was time for the Harvey to go home. Everyone on the boat had never seen anything so terrible. And they had never felt so proud.” That sums up the thrill and horror of that day as well as anything I’ve read, and the story of a gallant little boat frames it in a way that little children can get their thoughts around. Maira Kalman’s exuberant brushwork pictures the chaos as a bouquet of exploding paint splashes and strokes: the double-page spread of the crashed buildings is especially impressive (though the people figures should be smaller for a better sense of scale). Telling a big story through a small focus works for kids, who wouldn’t be able to grasp it any other way.
The Little Chapel that Stood, by A. B. Curtis, illustrated by Mirto Golino. Old Castle Publishing, 2003, 40
“Around the chapel of Old St. Paul/Blow the dancing leaves of the coming fall./In the morning breeze they leap and fly/beneath the towers that scrape the sky.” St. Paul’s Chapel is the oldest church structure in Manhattan; George Washington worshipped there while serving as President. The building has survived fires, storms, and surges, and on 9/11/01 it survived the collapse, practically next door, of the tallest buildings in New York. Though smoke and dust damaged the organ (which has since been repaired), the Chapel itself was miraculously unharmed. The introduction poignantly tells how firemen “hung their shoes on the iron fence as they pulled on their boots. Many brave firemen never returned to get their shoes.” The verse that tells this story is mostly pedestrian and the artwork is only adequate, but the story itself needs to be told–for its loaded symbolism, if nothing else.
“A bright morning sun lit a cloudless blue sky. America started its day. Highways filled with traffic. Railroads rumbled with trains. Airports roared with jetliners. Among the hundreds of planes rising into that flawless blue sky were two from Boston, one from Newark, New Jersey, and one from Washington D. C. Among their ordinary passengers were nineteen deadly men.” The author wastes no words setting the scene, but we get the picture, and the story continues with indelible snapshots, snatches of actual dialogue, and personal vignettes. Two fire-fighter brothers share a moment in the North Tower lobby before parting company forever. Firemen trotting up the thousand-foot stairwell carrying 80 pounds of gear have to pause at every tenth floor just to catch a breath. Line-and-wash drawings capture faces staring up in horror. Without gore or sensationalism, the author communicates the personal cost of that day (including the 15 residents of his home town, to whom this book is dedicated). A historical note at the end tallies the casualties and summarizes America’s immediate response. This is probably the best book I’ve seen for conveying a sense of shock and immediacy to 9/11.
I Survived the Attacks of September 11, 2001, by Lauren Tarshis, Scholastic: 2012, 112 pages. Age/interest level: 8-16.
“Eleven-year-old Lucas Calley wasn’t supposed to be in Manhattan that day. His parents had no idea that he’s caught a train into
This title is part of the “I Survived” paperback series in the age category known as high-low: high interest level, low reading skills. They are geared toward older, struggling readers: set in large type with fewer words on a page, but taking on more mature subjects than insomniac little badgers and frog-and-toad friendships. I confess that I didn’t get to read all the way to the end of this one, but I appreciated the strong family theme and manly role models. Reluctant readers in your house, especially of the male variety, may enjoy other disasters in the series: I Survived the Bombing of pearl Harbor, the San Francisco Earthquake, the Sinking of the Titanic, Hurricane Katrina, and The Shark Attacks of 1916 (Shark attacks in 1916?? Cool!)
We Are America: A Tribute from the Heart, by Walter Dean Myers, illustrated by Christopher Myers. HarperCollins, 2011, 37 pages. Age/interest level: 12-up
For grownups, I haven’t seen a good book-length treatment of what it all means for Christians, but Table Talk Magazine has made their tenth-anniversary issue available online, with commentary by R. C. Sproul and John McArthur, among others. Karen Kingsbury wrote a series of 9/11 novels for the Christian market, but I haven’t read them. For a broader perspective, Joel C. Rosenberg looks to the Muslim world with his booklet, Inside the Revival: Good News and Changed Hearts Since 9/11. God does have a way of bringing good out of bad, even though we may never know most of it in this world. But some day we will.
Stay Up to Date!
Get the information you need to make wise choices about books for your children and teens.
Our weekly newsletter includes our latest reviews, related links from around the web, a featured book list, book trivia, and more. We never sell your information. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Support our writers and help keep Redeemed Reader ad-free by joining the Redeemed Reader Fellowship.
Stay Up to Date!
Get the information you need to make wise choices about books for your children and teens.
Our weekly newsletter includes our latest reviews, related links from around the web, a featured book list, book trivia, and more. We never sell your information. You may unsubscribe at any time.
FREE Bible Guide!
Get a guide to the Best Bibles for Children and Teens. Perfect for an Easter gift.
We'd love to hear from you!
Our comments are now limited to our members (both Silver and Golden Key). Members, you just need to log in with your normal log-in credentials!
Not a member yet? You can join the Silver Key ($2.99/month) for a free 2-week trial. Cancel at any time. Find out more about membership here.
1 Comments
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.
My 5 yo son picked up the fireboat book from the library and I didn’t realize that it was about 9-11 until we started reading it. It is well done and we enjoyed it.